The Moment
Let's be precise about what this film is: a $4 million mockumentary in which Charli XCX — pop music's reigning progressive icon — produces, co-wrote, and stars in a fictional version of her own real life, distributed by A24, the most ideologically consistent prestige label in American cinema.…
Full analysis belowThis film draws you in for a significant portion of its runtime with traditional or neutral content before springing its woke agenda. Know before you go!
Severe woke trap. 70–75% of runtime delivers progressive ideology with 88% authenticity — experienced as art, not agenda. The entire film validates the 'Brat' lifestyle as the correct orientation toward life. Male authority figures are uniformly buffoonish or controlling. Anti-traditional family values presented as liberation and moral victory.
Let's be precise about what this film is: a $4 million mockumentary in which Charli XCX — pop music's reigning progressive icon — produces, co-wrote, and stars in a fictional version of her own real life, distributed by A24, the most ideologically consistent prestige label in American cinema. The "Brat Summer" phenomenon of 2024 — lime green aesthetic, feminist anti-establishment messaging, explicit sexual identity celebration — is not the backdrop of this film. It is the thesis. The Moment is less a movie than a 103-minute manifesto dressed in compelling cinematography and genuine comedic talent.
Here is the credit to the film before we proceed with the critique: director Aidan Zamiri (making his feature debut after years of music video work) is genuinely talented. Cinematographer Sean Price Williams (Good Time, Funny Pages) shoots the film with gritty handheld energy that makes it feel alive. Alexander Skarsgård is brilliantly funny as the pompous male filmmaker who wants to "sanitize" Charli's vision into something "family-oriented" — and in a more balanced film, his character would be a genuine critique of artistic commodification. But The Moment isn't interested in balance. Every male character exists to be wrong. Every female figure exists to be right. The ideology isn't delivered with a sledgehammer; it's delivered with style and wit, which is what makes it worth taking seriously as a cultural document.
In the aftermath of the "Brat Summer" cultural wave, Charli XCX is preparing her arena tour debut while her record label — Atlantic Records — pressures her to extend the commercial moment with brand deals she finds artistically compromising. The flashpoint is a "Brat" credit card partnership with a struggling bank, which Charli publicly rejects. The label responds by bringing in Johannes Godwin (Skarsgård), a pretentious documentary filmmaker, to produce an Amazon Music concert film — with the condition that he has full creative control and intends to reshape the tour's aesthetic into something "broadly appealing" (i.e., not Brat).
Charli's close friend and creative director Celeste (Sennott) becomes a locus of creative resistance. The film chronicles the tensions between Charli's artistic authenticity, corporate pressure, and the industry machinery that wants to own the cultural moment she created. Various celebrity figures orbit the story in cameo-style appearances.
The resolution — which the film telegraphs from its first frame — is that Charli chooses Brat, rejects the sanitized version, and preserves her "authentic" self. The industry loses; the artist wins; the audience is presumably meant to feel that justice has been served.
Aidan Zamiri is a music video director making his feature debut. His music video work has been largely for progressive pop artists. The Moment is his feature calling card, and it is ideologically fully aligned with his professional world — the intersection of progressive pop culture, sexual identity politics, and anti-institutional feminism. There is no counter-evidence to suggest any ideological complexity. His commitment to the material is genuine, which is both artistically commendable and ideologically transparent.
A24 has distributed Hereditary, Midsommar, Everything Everywhere All at Once, Past Lives, Bottoms, and Queer — a distribution slate that skews reliably progressive in its social content. A24 selecting The Moment for distribution is itself a data point.
| Trope | Category | Location | Authenticity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Female Artistic Genius Constrained by Corrupt Male Institutional Power | WOKE | Absolute Core — the entire film's premise and resolution | Authentic — Charli XCX produced and wrote the film; this is genuine conviction, not calculated positioning |
| Male Authority Figures Uniformly Buffoonish or Sinister | WOKE | Core — Johannes, label executives; every male character exists to be wrong | Authentic — deliberate and consistent throughout |
| Female Solidarity as the Supreme Relational and Creative Form | WOKE | Core — Charli and Celeste's creative sisterhood as the film's emotional center | Authentic — consistently foregrounded over all other relationships |
| Progressive Celebrity Ecosystem as Aspirational In-Group | WOKE | Supporting — Kylie Jenner, Julia Fox, and other progressive celebrity cameos as cultural endorsements | Authentic — functions as real-world ideological endorsement within the film |
| Anti-Family / Anti-Sanitization as Moral Victory — Brat Identity Over Conventional Values | WOKE | Core — resolution explicitly validates Brat lifestyle over 'family-friendly' version of self | Authentic — the film's thesis; not subtext |
| Critique of Corporate Commodification | TRADITIONAL | Supporting — anti-corporate dimension has traditional resonance | Mixed — form (artistic integrity vs. commercialism) is traditional; content (what Brat represents) is not |
| Artist Insisting on Authentic Self-Expression Over Market Pressure | TRADITIONAL | Core — the film's surface moral framework | Mixed — form is traditional; the 'authentic self' is defined by values antithetical to traditional social conservatism |
Director: Aidan Zamiri
PROGRESSIVEBritish music video director making his feature debut. Built his career directing music videos for progressive pop artists. The Moment reflects genuine artistic belief in progressive pop culture, sexual identity politics, and anti-institutional feminism. Feature directorial debut; ideologically fully aligned with the Brat pop world.
Writer: Aidan Zamiri & Bertie Brandes
Story by Charli XCX. Fully aligned with progressive pop culture industry worldview. No counter-evidence of ideological complexity.
Fidelity Casting Analysis N/A
Original story based on Charli XCX's own experiences — no source fidelity issue.
N/A — Original story by Charli XCX.
Adult Viewer Insight
The Moment is a well-made film in service of a worldview most VirtueVigil readers will find directly contrary to their values. That's not the same as saying it lacks merit — it has real cinematic intelligence and Skarsgård's performance is genuinely hilarious. But the ideological content is not incidental; it is the point. Adults who choose to see it with that understanding will find an interesting cultural artifact. Adults who go in unaware may find themselves nodding along to premises they should be interrogating. The film's modest box office ($3.5M against a $4M budget) reflects A24 prestige-indie limits, not cultural rejection. Among the film's target audience, it performed as intended. Recommended for adults who want to understand contemporary progressive pop culture from the inside.
Parental Guidance
The issue with The Moment for traditional families is not the surface-level content ratings — it's the worldview. The film actively argues that traditional, 'sanitized,' family-friendly values represent creative and personal death. This is not subtext; it's the plot. Parents should treat this as ideologically incompatible with conservative household values, not merely inappropriate due to content. Strong language throughout. Sexual references, mature themes, provocative imagery from the Brat aesthetic. Drug and alcohol use referenced and depicted. Recommended for adults only. Not for anyone under 18 or for traditional families.
Community Discussion 0
Subscribe to comment.
Join the VirtueVigil community to share your perspective on this review.