The Shape of Water
Guillermo del Toro's The Shape of Water won the Academy Award for Best Picture in 2018, and watching it nearly a decade later, the VVWS assessment lands at WOKE……
Want to know what's safe to watch? Get our weekly guide to new reviews and woke-free picks. No spam, ever.
Guillermo del Toro's The Shape of Water won the Academy Award for Best Picture in 2018, and watching it nearly a decade later, the VVWS assessment lands at WOKE (-10.01 margin). The film is a Cold War fairy tale about Elisa Esposito (Sally Hawkins), a mute janitor at a government aerospace facility who discovers an amphibian creature held captive by the lab and falls in love with it. Del Toro constructs a story in which every marginalized identity -- the mute, the gay, the Black, the non-human -- finds solidarity against the straight white patriarchal order embodied by Richard Strickland (Michael Shannon), a sadistic government agent with a cattle prod and a rotting set of fingers. The film is visually ravishing and emotionally sincere. It also announces its political loyalties with a bullhorn. Strickland is not a character; he is an indictment. He represents everything the film despises: American militarism, traditional masculinity, patriarchal control, and racial hierarchy. His sex with his wife is perfunctory and sterile, while Elisa's love for the creature is tender and transcendent. The film does not argue for its worldview -- it assumes it. By the time Giles (Richard Jenkins) delivers a line about being born 'either too early or too late,' the audience has already been sorted into those who will weep at the beauty of the marginalized finding each other and those who will notice they have been attending a sermon. The film's traditional virtues are real but peripheral. Elisa's willingness to sacrifice herself for the creature is a genuinely moving expression of selfless love. Her determination to protect an innocent being from torture is honorable. Zelda (Octavia Spencer) is a loyal friend. But the film frames these virtues as resistance to patriarchal order, not as goods in themselves. Love is valid here only when it transgresses boundaries; sacrifice is praiseworthy only when it defies authority. The VVWS verdict is WOKE, not STRONGLY WOKE, because del Toro is a genuine auteur making art he believes in. This is not a committee-built diversity product. It is a director's vision, executed with craft and passion. But that vision is fundamentally progressive in its moral architecture, and the film never complicates its own premises. Strickland remains a monster. The creature remains an innocent. The government remains evil. The counterculture remains righteous. That is not storytelling with tension; it is storytelling with a predetermined conclusion.
Adult Viewer Insight
The Shape of Water is Guillermo del Toro at his most emotionally unguarded, and for viewers who share his romantic sensibility -- that monsters are the true outsiders and outsiders are the true heroes -- the film is a transporting experience. Sally Hawkins delivers a performance entirely without spoken dialogue that carries the film's considerable emotional weight. Michael Shannon, tasked with playing a one-note villain, gives Strickland a physicality and menace that almost transcends the thinness of the writing. The creature design is a triumph of practical effects, and the underwater cinematography by Dan Laustsen is luminous. The film's weakness, from the VVWS perspective, is its refusal to grant any interiority to the traditional world it condemns. Strickland has no complexity, no motivation beyond cruelty, no moment of doubt. He is a punching bag for the film's moral certainty. Compare this to the villains in del Toro's own Pan's Labyrinth: Captain Vidal is monstrous, but he is also a human being with a wound you can see. Strickland is Vidal without the wound. That difference is instructive. When a film cannot imagine what it opposes, it cannot persuade anyone who does not already agree. The Shape of Water preaches to the choir beautifully, but it is still preaching. For viewers who can accept the sermon in exchange for the craft, the film remains a striking achievement. For those who notice they are being lectured, the craft may not be enough.
Parental Guidance
The Shape of Water is rated R for sexual content, graphic nudity, violence, and language. It is not suitable for children or most teenagers. The film contains full-frontal nudity (both human and creature), a scene of female masturbation, and an implied sexual relationship between a woman and a non-human creature. Violence includes a man's fingers being bitten off (shown graphically), a cat being eaten, a man being shot in the face, and repeated scenes of torture and electrocution of a captive creature. Language is strong throughout, including racial slurs and sexual harassment. The film's moral framework portrays traditional heterosexual marriage as sterile and unfulfilling, which may conflict with some families' values. Recommended for adults only. For older teens (17+), the film could provide productive discussion material about how art can be simultaneously beautiful in execution and ideologically one-sided in argument. Parents should know the creature-human romance is central and explicit, and the film's treatment of sexuality is frank and adult.
Formula: Weighted Score = Severity × Authenticity Multiplier × Centrality Multiplier
🔴 Woke Tropes
| Trope | Severity | Authenticity | Centrality | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Toxic Masculinity Critique | 5 | Low | High | 2.7 |
| Chosen Family over Bio-Kin | 5 | High | High | 6.3 |
| Institutional Evil | 4 | Moderate | High | 3.6 |
| The Girl Boss | 4 | Moderate | High | 3.6 |
| Heteronormativity as Harm | 3 | Moderate | Low | 0.75 |
| Anti-Western Revisionism | 3 | Low | Moderate | 0.9 |
| TOTAL WOKE | 17.8 | |||
🟢 Traditional Tropes
| Trope | Severity | Authenticity | Centrality | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Self-Sacrificing Hero | 4 | High | High | 5.04 |
| Defense of the Innocent | 3 | High | Moderate | 2.1 |
| The Forgiving Heart | 2 | High | Low | 0.7 |
| TOTAL TRADITIONAL | 7.8 | |||
Score Margin: -10.01 WOKE
Read Full Analysis
Community Discussion
View AllIt's a fun show but it has some of the dumbest male characters in recent memory who exist to make the women seems brilliant by comparison. That said, It is somewhat balanced by ...
You neglected to include the woke trope of Colin's business partner Chiara, who is married to a man and starts a lesbian relationship with one of Ashley's friends. She leaves th...
Your website is a great resource and has potential for growth in popularity. That said, I have the impression that some reviews like this one are written without having watched ...
This is a different take from the other reviews I read (The Federalist, The Washington Examiner and Time) The first two, from conservative publications, felt that the moral of t...
" it reveals the limits of an entertainment industry that can only tell one kind of story about gender and power: the one where men are monsters and women, even murderous ones, ...