Brokeback Mountain
Brokeback Mountain is the rare film that is both a landmark of progressive culture and a deeply traditional tragedy.…
Full analysis below
Want to know what's safe to watch? Get our weekly guide to new reviews and woke-free picks. No spam, ever.
Brokeback Mountain is not a woke trap. The film's depiction of a same-sex relationship is its entire premise, openly advertised from the poster to the trailer to the awards campaign. There is no hidden agenda because the agenda is the movie. Audiences in 2005 knew exactly what they were buying a ticket to see, and the film's critical and commercial success came from the honesty with which it delivered on that premise. A woke trap requires concealment, and Brokeback Mountain conceals nothing.
Our Verdict on Brokeback Mountain
Brokeback Mountain is the rare film that is both a landmark of progressive culture and a deeply traditional tragedy. Ang Lee's adaptation of Annie Proulx's short story follows Ennis Del Mar and Jack Twist, two Wyoming ranch hands who spend a summer herding sheep on Brokeback Mountain in 1963 and fall into a sexual and romantic relationship that neither man has the vocabulary for. They marry women, have children, and spend the next twenty years stealing weekends together in the wilderness while their families crumble around them. The film ends with Jack dead, possibly murdered in a hate crime, and Ennis alone in a trailer with a postcard of Brokeback Mountain and a shirt that still smells like the man he loved. Heath Ledger gives one of the great screen performances as Ennis, a man so clenched that even his vowels are strangled. Jake Gyllenhaal's Jack is the one who believes love can conquer all, and the film's tragedy is that he is wrong. Brokeback Mountain is not a political argument dressed as a movie. It is a love story that happens to be politically charged because of who is doing the loving. The film's neutrality score reflects a genuine balance: its progressive sexual politics are offset by its traditional treatment of marriage, infidelity, consequence, and the weight of a world that does not care about your feelings.
Director: Ang Lee
NONE (Universal Humanist)Ang Lee may be the least ideological major director working. He has made films about gay cowboys (Brokeback Mountain), Chinese martial artists (Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon), Marvel superheroes (Hulk), Jane Austen adaptations (Sense and Sensibility), and a boy adrift at sea with a tiger (Life of Pi). His subject is not politics but human longing, and his gift is finding the universal in the specific. Brokeback Mountain is not a political film in Lee's hands. It is a love story that happens to be between two men, and Lee approaches it with the same classical restraint he brought to Sense and Sensibility. This is the film's great strength and also, from a VVWS perspective, what makes its ideological content so difficult to categorize.
Writer: Larry McMurtry, Diana Ossana
Larry McMurtry was one of the great chroniclers of the American West (Lonesome Dove, The Last Picture Show) and brought to Brokeback Mountain a deep understanding of Western masculinity and its costs. Diana Ossana discovered Annie Proulx's short story in The New Yorker and pursued the adaptation for years before McMurtry agreed to collaborate. The screenplay's great achievement is expanding a 30-page short story into a feature film without adding ideological commentary. The script tells the story that Proulx wrote, with the same restraint and the same refusal to editorialize.
Producers
Full Cast
Content Breakdown
Adult Viewer Insight
Brokeback Mountain is a film about what happens when you cannot say what you mean. Ennis Del Mar's entire life is a failure of communication. He cannot tell Jack he loves him. He cannot tell Alma the truth. He cannot even tell himself what he is. The film's great insight is not about homosexuality but about inarticulacy: the tragedy of a man who feels everything and can express nothing. Heath Ledger's performance is built on this insight. Every mumbled line, every averted glance, every explosive burst of violence is the language of a man who was never taught to speak. The film is devastating because it shows what that costs: a life half-lived, a love never fully claimed, and a future that could have been different if either man had possessed the words to make it so. Brokeback Mountain endures not because it is a political film but because it is a human one, and the boundary between those two categories is the space where the best art lives.
Parental Guidance
Rated R for sexual content including a brief but explicit sex scene, nudity, and strong thematic material. The sexual content is not pornographic but is frank. Language is period-appropriate and includes homophobic slurs. The film deals with adult themes including infidelity, divorce, and homophobic violence including an implied hate crime murder. The emotional content is heavy and the ending is devastating. Not appropriate for children or young teens. Older teenagers (16+) may find value in the film's treatment of love, loss, and the cost of living inauthentically, but parents should be aware that the film treats a same-sex relationship with full dramatic legitimacy. Parents who object to that framing on moral grounds should know that the film's emotional power makes it unusually persuasive. The film is likely to prompt conversations about sexuality, marriage, and social tolerance that parents may or may not want to have with their teenagers.
Find Brokeback Mountain on Amazon Prime Video, rent, or buy:
▶ Stream or Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, VirtueVigil earns from qualifying purchases.
Community Discussion 0
Subscribe to comment.
Join the VirtueVigil community to share your perspective on this review.