Madame Web

Our Verdict on Madame Web

Madame Web is one of the most comprehensively terrible superhero films ever produced by a major studio. It earned an 11% on Rotten Tomatoes, grossed $100.5 million worldwide against a budget of $80-100 million (a catastrophic loss after marketing costs), and won three Golden Raspberry Awards: Worst Picture, Worst Actress, and Worst Screenplay. These accolades are all deserved.

The premise is this: Cassandra Webb (Dakota Johnson) is a New York City paramedic who, after a near-death experience, begins having visions of the future. She discovers that a villain named Ezekiel Sims (Tahar Rahim) is hunting three teenage girls, Julia Cornwall (Sydney Sweeney), Anya Corazon (Isabela Merced), and Mattie Franklin (Celeste O'Connor), because he has foreseen that they will become Spider-Women and kill him. Cassie must protect the girls, confront the truth about her mother's death in the Amazon, and learn to control her clairvoyant powers.

On paper, this is workable. A reluctant mentor with psychic abilities protecting three future heroes from a precognitive villain is a perfectly fine structure for a superhero origin story. The problem is execution. Every single element fails.

The script, credited to four writers including the team responsible for Morbius, is a disaster of convenience and contrivance. Characters make decisions that no rational person would ever make because the plot requires them to. Cassie is wanted for kidnapping and possibly murder, yet she walks freely through New York City, boards an international flight to Peru, and moves around without taking basic precautions to hide her identity. She arrives in the Peruvian Amazon and immediately finds the exact person she is looking for. A wonder bar appears beneath a parked car at the precise moment she needs it. The three teenagers are told to stay put and promptly leave to go to a diner, where the villain naturally finds them. This happens not once but repeatedly. The film's plot runs entirely on characters being stupid enough to create danger.

Dakota Johnson's lead performance has become legendary for the wrong reasons. She delivers every line with the emotional investment of someone waiting for a delayed flight. In scenes requiring fear, urgency, or grief, she barely registers a pulse. There are moments when people die in front of her and her reaction suggests mild annoyance rather than horror. Whether this is a performance choice (playing Cassie as emotionally numb), a direction failure (Clarkson not getting the range she needed), or simply disinterest (Johnson visibly did not want to be here), the result is a protagonist you cannot care about because she does not appear to care about anything herself.

Tahar Rahim's villain fares even worse, though through less fault of his own. Rahim is a genuinely talented actor. His performance in A Prophet is electrifying. Here, the studio apparently changed significant amounts of his dialogue in post-production, resulting in ADR dubbing that frequently does not match his lip movements. The effect is disorienting and unintentionally hilarious. He looks like a foreign film that has been badly dubbed into English, except this is supposed to be the final product. His motivation (kill teenagers before they kill him) is paper-thin, and his powers (vague spider abilities plus a black-and-red suit) make him a discount Spider-Man fighting a discount psychic.

The three young actresses are wasted. Sweeney, Merced, and O'Connor have varying degrees of talent, but the script gives them nothing to play except victims who need saving. We see them in their Spider-Women costumes only in brief flash-forward visions. The entire film is essentially a prologue to the story you want to see, and that story never arrives. Sony cannot actually use Spider-Man in these films, so the Spider-Women tease is all tease and no payoff.

The ideological content is mild and mostly botched. The film clearly wants to be a female empowerment story: a woman discovers her power, mentors three young women, and defeats a male villain through cunning rather than brute force. But the execution is so limp that the empowerment message never lands. Cassie does not feel empowered. She feels confused and annoyed for two hours and then the movie ends. The three girls do not grow into heroes. They remain passive throughout.

There are specific woke markers. Anya Corazon's backstory involves her father being deported, leaving her alone. One character wears a shirt with a slogan about girls and math. A baby shower scene contrasts Cassie's abrasive independence against traditionally feminine women who are written as shallow. But none of it coheres into an ideological project because the filmmakers were too incompetent to execute one. The wokeness is there in the ingredients but the recipe is burned beyond recognition.

The traditional elements, what few exist, are genuine. The maternal thread is the film's strongest asset. Cassie's mother died trying to save her from a congenital illness. Cassie's arc is about accepting the same responsibility: she becomes the protector of three vulnerable girls because that is what her mother would have done. The self-sacrifice theme is real. Cassie ends the film blind and paraplegic, having absorbed the physical cost of protecting others. That is a traditional heroism arc played straight, and it is the one thing the film does not completely botch.

Adam Scott's Ben Parker provides the film's only warmth. His scenes with Johnson are the one relationship in the film that feels like actual human interaction. His character's kindness, reliability, and quiet decency are traditionally masculine virtues played without irony.

But these elements cannot rescue the film from its fundamental problems: a script that insults the audience's intelligence, a lead performance that registers as checked out, a villain whose audio does not sync with his mouth, pacing that lurches between boring and baffling, and CGI that looks like it was rendered on a deadline three weeks too tight.

Madame Web is not a culture-war flashpoint. It is not offensive enough to provoke outrage or good enough to earn defense. It is simply bad. Impressively, consistently, almost fascinatingly bad. The kind of bad where you stop being angry and start being curious about how so many professionals at a major studio looked at this film and said yes, this is ready for theaters. The answer, as usual with Sony's Spider-Man Universe, is that the studio's desperation to exploit its Marvel IP license overrode every creative instinct that might have saved the project.

The film's lasting cultural contribution is becoming a punchline. The memes are funnier than the movie. Dakota Johnson's dead-eyed press tour became more entertaining than her performance. Tahar Rahim's dubbed dialogue became more discussed than his character's motivation. And the line from the trailer, "He was in the Amazon with my mom when she was researching spiders right before she died," became shorthand for clumsy exposition in an era that was already drowning in it.

Sony killed the Spider-Man Universe shortly after this film's release. Good.

Woke Tropes & Content Analysis

Formula: Weighted Score = Severity × Authenticity Multiplier × Centrality Multiplier

🔴 Woke Tropes

Trope	Severity	Authenticity	Centrality	Score
All-Female Hero Ensemble	3	0.6	1	2.88
Girl-Boss Empowerment Without Earning It	3	0.5	0.8	2.34
Immigration as Sympathetic Backstory	2	0.5	0.3	1.14
Traditional Femininity Mocked	2	0.5	0.2	0.88
Girls-in-STEM Signaling	1	0.4	0.1	0.38
Mystical Indigenous People as Plot Device	2	0.4	0.5	1.36
TOTAL WOKE				9.0

🟢 Traditional Tropes

Trope	Severity	Authenticity	Centrality	Score
Maternal Sacrifice as Central Theme	4	0.8	0.9	3.84
Self-Sacrifice for the Innocent	4	0.8	0.8	3.49
Reliable Male Decency (Ben Parker)	2	0.9	0.4	1.82
TOTAL TRADITIONAL				9.2

Score Margin: 0 BALANCED

Content Breakdown

Is Madame Web Safe for Kids?